Chapter 3 - Engineering as Performance - An "Experiential Gestalt" for understanding Engineering

 




Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Chapter 26 Object-Oriented Method and the Relationship Between Structure and Function of Technical Artifacts

Image
  Abstract The abstract discusses a challenge in the philosophy of technology and engineering science regarding the relationship between the structure and function of a technical artifact. The key points are: Challenge in Philosophy of Technology and Engineering Science: There's a need to understand the relationship between a technical artifact's structure (how it's built) and its function (what it does). However, current philosophical approaches in technology and engineering science struggle to support the idea that a significant relationship exists between these two aspects. Empirical Turn and Functional Decomposition: The Empirical Turn, a recent development in the philosophy of technology and engineering science, attempts to address this issue. Jeroen de Ridder's 'Functional Decomposition' is a reductive design methodology presented in this context. It attempts to explain the structure-function relationship through rational reconstruction, which is a method ...
Read more

Chapter 9 Engineering as Willing

Image
  Part I Reflections on Practice Abstract The abstract argues that while science is seen as a systematic approach to acquiring knowledge, engineering should be viewed as a systematic approach to applying will. Using Bernard Lonergan's transcendental precepts as a backdrop, it compares scientific and engineering methods. In science, the intellect is primary, aiming for objective knowledge. In contrast, engineering prioritizes the will, focusing on pragmatic, subjective outcomes often determined by managers or clients, not the engineers themselves. Engineering problems are usually not well-defined and require heuristic approaches, leading to diverse solutions and models from different engineers, none of which is definitively correct. Engineering decision-making involves necessary trade-offs, making it more intentional than rational. The abstract suggests that recognizing the intentional nature of engineering can help society value willing as much as knowing and involve engineers more...
Read more

Chapter 7 Future Reflective Practitioners: The Contributions of Philosophy

Image
 Part I Reflections on Practice Abstract This paper discusses the importance of integrating philosophy into engineering education, emphasizing its role in shaping reflective and responsible future practitioners. It argues that not only ethics but also other philosophical fields like the history of scientific ideas, philosophy of mind, science, technology, and engineering are crucial. The concept of 'responsibility' is defined broadly, encompassing everything from specific design decisions to moral attitudes. The paper advocates for teaching future engineers to critically analyze their tools, methods, and outcomes. This approach is based on the authors' experiences teaching a philosophy course to computer engineering students at Politecnico di Milano, Italy. 7.1 Introduction The introduction to this paper highlights the underexplored yet significant role of philosophy in engineering education. It emphasizes the need for reflection in engineering practice and how this is infl...
Read more